CAMERON, Mo. — Despite a state report that says otherwise, a Kansas City personal injury law firm told residents Saturday that their five-month investigation shows a larger than expected number of cancer cases among the town’s 6,500 residents.
Dr. James Dahlgren, a California toxicology expert made famous by a movie about Erin Brockovich, said the high incidences are the aftereffects of the former Rockwool Industries insulation plant, which operated in Cameron for 18 years, between 1974 and 1992.
Ms. Brockovich was to speak in Cameron on Monday, but organizers said she postponed due to a scheduling conflict.
Saturday’s town hall meeting was attended by about 50 residents — many themselves diagnosed with brain tumors.
It came just two days after another town hall meeting in which a state epidemiologist told residents that brain tumor cases in a four-county area near Cameron isn’t statistically higher than the numbers throughout the state.
Dr. Dahlgren said the law firm he has been hired by — Peterson and Associates — is representing about 40 brain tumor cases in Cameron.
Citing a town population of 6,500, he said that number is “higher than it should be” when considering 15 out of 100,000 malignant cancer cases would be a high incidence in any other part of the country.
Answering an audience question about the validity of the state investigation, Dr. Dahlgren said his experience as an expert on numerous toxic exposure cases across the country has been that the state investigates the community in a way so that they’re not compelled into action and made to run into “a political buzzsaw.”
He said the town’s drinking water doesn’t appear to be the source.
Attorney Dave Peterson said his firm has been investigating the matter since news about Cameron contamination fallout broke in May.
Through independent water and soil tests as well as multiple interviews, he said the firm has determined that slag — a lava-like by-product of producing mineral wool — tests higher for arsenic and lead in samples taken in Cameron.
State health officials previously reported that the high levels of lead and arsenic were not to the health threat level and that they had no proof that the metals reached people through ingestion, inhalation or skin contact.
However, attorneys said Saturday that they’ve interviewed witnesses and have uncovered likely legal violations relating to the Rockwool facility. Mr. Peterson said the company “surreptitiously” burned materials in violation of environmental laws.
Before the town hall meeting, residents lined up to view a map locating many brain tumor patients in the area.
“It’s so serious with that plant there,” said one elderly woman.
“I live right there,” another man said.
“And these are the people that we are just aware of,” said Attorney Todd Matthews.
Attorneys actively noted names of possible tumor victims.
Ahmad Safi can be reached at ahmadsafi@npgco.com.
More of the same.
Elected officials ignoring health-risks so as not to get, "caught in a political buzzsaw."
And people think this presidential election is somehow different. It's just bigger. And more frightening.
I sympathize with my brothers and sisters in Cameron. I hope you find peace soon.
Posted by 238er on October 12, 2008 at 2:15 p.m. (Suggest removal)This guy is just a prostitute. Brockovich is no more. They basically blackmailed PGE into a settlement since the risks were less than a jury.
See http://fumento.com/mickeyerin.html
The rate of cancers in Cameron is no higher than the general Missouri rate. Folks in Cameron want someone to blame, but there is no one. I speak as someone who lost a spouse to a rare cancer.
Posted by need_answers on October 12, 2008 at 3:28 p.m. (Suggest removal)Its a horrible situation in Cameron, they need someone to help them find answers. Its possible the cancer rate is not higher but the TUMOR rates are alarming. A lot of folks don't believe every line our government feeds us... so we need to hear from other credible sources... I am not saying that this Peterson is the right guy, i'm just saying I can understand why.
Do you really think PGE would just give away $333 million dollars for no reason, come on they were guilty & they knew it or they wouldn't have settled thats a lot of dough even for PGE.
Posted by Rockchalk on October 12, 2008 at 6:26 p.m. (Suggest removal)Dahlgren is a hired gun for plaintiffs' attorneys nationwide. He will say whatever he has to to support the plaintiffs' position, regardless of the facts. Most of his "studies" are severely flawed. In fact, his testimony has come into question in a number of major lawsuits.
In Texas, the appellate court upheld a trial court's grant of Summary Judgment in which Dahlgren was the plaintiff's expert. The court found there was "no reliable scientific evidence to connect appellants' exposure to [an alleged carcinogen] to appellants' injuries other than the unsupported assertion of Dr. Dahlgren".
In a similar situation, the California Supreme Court ruled against the plaintiff, noting that Dr. Dahlgren's conclusory testimony was not "substantial evidence" on the issue of cancer causation.
In addition to his questionable epidemiology "studies", Dr. Dahlgren is medical director of BWell Clinic in California which uses Scientology's detoxification treatment program to allegedly "treat" patients' exposure to environmental toxins.
It's understandable that when something bad happens, people want someone to blame. However, not every bad thing is cause for a lawsuit. It's a shame that this lawfirm and this "expert" are preying on this community's fear.
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them.
Rules: We don't allow comments that degrade others on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation or disability. Epithets, abusive language and obscene comments will not be tolerated... nor will defamation. Brief quotes are okay as long as the source is given. Blatent cutting and pasting is not acceptable.Robust, even heated debate we like. Straying off-topic or flaming, we don't. Please read our user agreement.
Requires free stjoenews.net registration.