Connie Leatherman said she doesn’t hear “please” and “thank you” much anymore. She doesn’t hear it when she lets someone cut in front of her in line at the grocery store. She doesn’t see it in a friendly wave for letting someone into traffic.
And cell phones. Don’t get the St. Joseph woman talking about cell phones. She even hates the one she owns.
“I think they’re terrible. I think people’s driving has gotten way worse because they’ve got a cell phone glued to the side of their head,” Ms. Leatherman said. “I’ve got one, but I don’t like them.”
Rudeness. Incivility. Those are the words that many feel describe the zeitgeist of our times. Perhaps we are in a time where rudeness and disrespectful behavior are the norm. Maybe we’re at a place and time where cussing is the national language and cell phones are our national symbol.
“Leave It to Beaver” and “Father Knows Best” — gentle, humorous sitcoms from the 1950s — have been replaced by “Roseanne” and “Family Guy,” shows that get laughs from rude and crass behavior. Our comedians, like Sarah Silverman and Lisa Lampanelli, use racist and sexist put-downs as humor.
We vote people off islands, we write hateful responses on blog sites, and talk radio is just an airwave highway for our road rage.
In 2006, ABC News took a poll on rudeness in America. The poll showed that 87 percent of Americans ranked annoying cell phone calls as the rudest of behaviors. This was followed by being rude and disrespectful, using bad language and using cell phone or e-mails in mid-conversation.
Blame cell phones, the economy, the war, the TV shows, the music, our kids or whatever. Many people feel we’re ruder and more uncivil today than we were yesterday.
Dr. Shirley Taylor, a licensed psychologist for Heartland Health Counseling Services, said she noticed the trend 20 years ago.
“I remember when I first saw ‘The Roseanne Show,’ actually, ‘The Bill Cosby Show,’ too,” she said. “There was a certain snootiness, a certain rudeness that really surprised me. In the popular culture, it was there, and I know that they always say that the media reflects the culture.”
Dr. Taylor said rudeness has always been with us. But it may be more crass today than it was 100 years ago. The classic put-downs of Mark Twain, Dorothy Parker and Ambrose Bierce had a cleverness that’s missing now.
“Now, words seem to club another person over the head. There’s not a cleverness or subtlety about it,” Dr. Taylor said. “We’re so clever, we say, ‘Screw you.’”
Many professionals believe the rudeness and crass behavior we’re experiencing today are the fruits of the 1960s freedom movement and liberal child-rearing philosophy of Dr. Benjamin Spock that was popular in the 1950s.
Dr. Spock was an American pediatrician, whose 1946 book, “Baby and Child Care,” championed permissive parenting. He believed that instead of strict discipline and corporal punishment, children should be reared with more understanding of their needs and wants.
“I think his book and the child-rearing that grew out of that probably took us to a place we needed to go,” Dr. Taylor said. “But maybe we need a correction now, where we don’t raise children with it all being about them, where we need to have a sense of more cooperation and respect for the other guy.”
Nancy Irwin, a Los Angeles psychotherapist and author, believes cell phones, e-mail and texting make us more self-centered.
“Technology can give us a false sense of being in control, to the exclusion of others’ needs or responses. The massive numbers of ‘connections’ we make now are disposable in a nano-second, void of any consideration deeper than the immediate need,” she said.
Dr. Ken Hines, a St. Joseph psychologist, said there was a time when we were taught manners in school and at home. Today, he said, we’ve become so hooked on instant gratification and so oblivious to the rights of others that we say some pretty horrible and hateful things.
“It is tempting to blame the cell phone and modern conveniences that are taken for granted,” he added. “But I believe the trend precedes the mechanisms of texting and chatting and getting back. I have noted increases in people talking aloud in movie theaters and at staged productions over the last 20 years.”
Dr. Hines added that new media, such as texting, Facebook and the like, merely capitalize on some primitive characteristics within us. Those socializing tools allow those characteristics to be expressed with little or no regard to importance or consequence.
“One of the hallmarks of being civilized is learning our proper place in the bigger picture, how to be considerate and thoughtful of others, how to behave in a civilized manner and how to feel when we have failed to behave properly and like we are supposed to,” he said.
Julie Frantz is owner and instructor of Everyday Etiquette, a Belvidere, Ill., organization that makes presentations on manners and social skills for schools and businesses. She also believes the rudeness phase began with the permissiveness of the 1960s. But she sees an increase in people wanting to learn better social skills.
“If all of us looked upon ourselves as agents of change, we need to all be moving toward building a better country that is going to be based on a foundation of civility,” she said. “We’re going to be kind, we’re going to be polite, we’re going to look out for each other. Courtesy and kindness are absolutely free.”
Billie Blair, president and chief executive officer of Change Strategists Inc., a California consulting firm, has a different take on rudeness. She says we need to be ruder.
Dr. Blair says we’ve become a nation of timid people who are afraid to say what we think. Most of it is a phony courteousness that puts us at a global disadvantage, when most of the world’s population is not so politically correct.
“Baby boomers are probably the major offenders. We are probably the ones who got this all started, being nice to one another, a completely phony way to be,” she said. “We spend so much time going around and around the barn, trying to say things gently so we won’t offend anybody at all.”
Dr. Blair says rudeness is really based on how a person perceives it. We have a choice to decide whether we’re offended.
“I think we need to encourage people to speak their case clearly, and if that comes across as rude, then there is a discussion there to have,” she said. “I suggest we need to get a plane higher than that, and not be so concerned about these things.”
Alonzo Weston can be reached
at alonzow@npgco.com.
You know something is wrong with society, when the children have to be taught in the school how to conduct themselves. (i.e. PACE Program). Manners should be taught from birth starting at home. Uncouth begats uncouth.
Hicktown, I absolutely agree with your comments but would suggest a more apt closing would be "uncouth BREEDS uncouth". Who can blame kids today when the young observe their own parents acting with zero self-respect and self control and with a self-absorption totally focused upon their own immediate gratification no matter what the impact to those around them, including their own children? Monkey see, monkey do........
I agree the children ( teenagers ) are rude people today and it does start with raising your children at home(with the parents). I was brought up to respect my elder and not to be a rude person and if I did not show respect I would be picking my teeth up off of the floor. My 3 children are being brought up to be respectfull citizens with manners, morals and values and they will respect their elders and will not be rude citizens. I have noticed when you do say excuse me or pardon me or are polite, people look at you like I cannot believe you said that to me as if they were surprised to hear. There is no reason to be rude disrespectful to anybody.
Teenagers who are rude should be picking themselves up off the floor not their teeth. At the very least they should be humiliated by being bent over someones knee and publicly spanked. Humiliation goes a long way towards curbing bad behavior in public. When I was a kid you didn't misbehave or be disrespectful because there were consequences, very painful ones, for acting that way. We learned at a pretty early age that waiting for Dad to get home to be punished was almost as painful as the actual spanking when he arrived. If you mouthed off, when you woke up from the initial shock of Dad's reply, you got another shock on the other end of your torso. These days the worst punishment kids get is being yelled at and they tune that out before it starts. My policy in business in the past has always been that people who are rude to me or my staff leave with their demands unmet and with the instruction not to return until they learn some manners. They usually do one of three things: 1) step back and shift attitude 2) leave and come back another time with new manners or 3) leave and never return. I have receive my share of standing ovations from the other customers who witnessed my handling of these rude customers. Managers need to get it through their heads that the customer is not always right. You don't cave just because they are rude and hateful. That just breeds more bad behavior. We must demand civility if we expect to get it. Throwing money or drinks at ne or my employees is assault and should be treated as a crime.
I totally agree about the cellphone comment. Don't understand why people cannot drive somewhere without a cellphone up to their ear. What is even more rude and irritating is when you go into a business and TRY to ask an employee a question and they immediately get on their cellphone to text or take a personal call, this is ridiculous. How did these people ever exist before cellphones?