Edward N. Pamir has no tie to British Columbia. He traveled to Vancouver in January to attend his father’s funeral.
Now, Mr. Pamir finds himself stuck in this picturesque Canadian seaport, a prisoner of long-ago missteps. Or maybe a clerical error. Or maybe just bad luck in an age of yellow threat-level suspicions.
He went to school in St. Joseph, married a woman with local roots, bought a house, held a job in the South Side for nearly the past 20 years. Planning for the future, he had a 401(k) account.
An American life.
Another American, this one staffing a border crossing between Vancouver and Seattle, had a different view. As the St. Joseph man tried to return to the United States after his father’s funeral, a U.S. Customs and Border Protection officer denied him entry.
In the eyes of the federal government, Mr. Pamir is not a legal resident of the United States.
This news began a nightmare that continues for Mr. Pamir. He remains a displaced soul in a country where he holds resident status but no personal connection. He believed himself an American citizen after going through the Ronald Reagan-initiated immigration amnesty program in 1986 but can produce no documents to prove his claim.
Worse, his wife died during his exile, a loss Mr. Pamir can’t put behind him because of not being able to return to St. Joseph.
He knocks around his late father’s apartment pondering regrets, most of them about ever leaving the United States. Would a person in doubt of his legal residency cross the border? The question comes rhetorically, Mr. Pamir knowing the answer carries no weight in the bureaucratic mess where he finds himself.
His phone calls from Canada offer a revolving tone of anger, despair, doubt, frustration and resignation.
“All I want to do is go home,” he says.
“EVERYBODY WENT CRAZY”
Edward Pamir was born 42 years ago in Campbellton, New Brunswick, the son of a doctor born in Turkey. In 1972, his parents moved him and his brother to the United States. Mr. Pamir would be a teenager before learning his pre-school entry into the United States was illegal.
After living for a time in the American Northeast, Mr. Pamir’s family came to St. Joseph when his father, Dr. Polon Pamir, applied for a job at the State Hospital. For the next 30 years, Northwest Missouri would be Edward’s home.
About 1990, he took a job with Ag Processing in St. Joseph. He married Debra A. Havner in June 1993, and they lived in St. Joseph.
Edward’s father died on Jan. 18 in Vancouver. Edward went to Canada for the funeral, flying to Seattle on Jan. 21 and driving the 140 miles north to Vancouver.
The return trip presented a problem. With U.S. soil in sight at the border crossing, officers detained Mr. Pamir for what he said was seven hours.
“Everybody went crazy,” Mr. Pamir remembered of the incident. “They treated us like we were terrorists.”
After that, he said, “They basically told me my status to work in the United States was revoked in 1992.”
Uncertain of his legal status in the United States, Mr. Pamir had filed paperwork in 1986 through the Immigration Reform and Control Act, whose amnesty provision legalized, by some estimates, 2.7 million undocumented workers.
If the federal government ever granted him residency status through that effort, it went away. An officer at the border suggested a clerical error might be at fault, Mr. Pamir said. The St. Joseph man said he never received notice of anything awry.
“Since he never received a letter from immigration, he continued to live his life,” said his sister, Susan Rogers, of Glen Allen, Va.
Ms. Rogers drove Mr. Pamir back to Vancouver, there to figure out the next step.
At the American consulate in that city, Mr. Pamir accepted a suggestion to get a Canadian birth certificate and try to cross the border as a visitor. Then, he could work to straighten out his problems from the American side.
A bad suggestion, it turned out. On Feb. 17, officers at the border took a dim view of this plan, Mr. Pamir said, denying him entry for five years.
The man retreated to Vancouver, contacted an immigration attorney suggested by his company and waited.
NOT A CARD, A STATUS
Those native to the United States have no real appreciation for the complexity of immigration laws. The bureaucracy alone is daunting.
The Department of State issues visas. Citizenship and Immigration Services adjudicates immigrant benefits. Customs and Border Protection watches the points of entry, and Immigration and Customs Enforcement detains and deports status violators.
Those going through the amnesty program of 1986 got permanent legal residence if they met all the requirements, though such a status can be revoked. People with that status can file for American citizenship after five years, though nothing compels that.
“There are people who live in this country as permanent residents their entire lives, and they have no problem with their green card coming in and out of the country,” said Mary Lou Cabrera, a spokeswoman for Citizenship and Immigration Services.
Neither Ms. Cabrera nor Carl Rusnok, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement spokesman, would speak to the specifics of the Pamir case. However, Mr. Rusnok said anyone who successfully completed the amnesty program would have gotten a green card designating legal residence.
“Permanent residence is not just a card, it’s a status,” he said from his office in Dallas. “If the card expires, you still have the status.”
Kevin L. Jamison, a Gladstone, Mo., attorney, handles immigration cases. While he knows nothing of the Pamir matter, he finds it plausible a clerical mistake might have led to the man’s predicament.
“I remember the amnesty program,” he said. “It was utter chaos.”
However, a green card cures many ills, the lawyer said, and even a lost card should be recoverable through certain steps. Mr. Jamison added though, “If he never got the card, then he’s got problems.”
David Brown, with Brown Immigration Law in Lincoln, Neb., represents Mr. Pamir. He has filed a Freedom of Information Act request to piece together what amnesty documents his client filed more than two decades ago.
“It’s hard to know which lever to push until you know what was done and what the mistake is you’re trying to correct,” Mr. Brown said.
The law turns unfavorable for a person outside the country who never had permanent legal residence status, Ms. Cabrera said.
“That opportunity doesn’t exist right now,” she said from the Chicago regional office. “There is no amnesty. There isn’t any way that someone that’s here unlawfully can change their status.”
“I’M JUST NUMB”
On Jan. 31, Debra Pamir died at age 48. Her husband could not make it back to St. Joseph to attend to the arrangements, which his mother-in-law handled.
“I didn’t get to say goodbye to my wife,” he said from Vancouver. “It’s doesn’t seem real to me. I’m just numb.”
Mr. Pamir trained for, then quit, a low-paying job at the Vancouver airport. His job remains open in St. Joseph, and he rents his St. Joseph house at 1712 S. 10th St. The days in Canada drag on, and it takes a toll on him and his family.
“Losing my dad, losing his wife, now I feel like I’ve lost my brother,” Ms. Rogers said.
Mr. Brown calls the process “in a holding pattern” until he can gather more information.
“This is definitely the first time I’ve had this kind of weird situation,” the attorney said, noting a post 9/11 urgency in all immigration matters. “There is less flexibility in the system when something goes wrong.”
As for Mr. Pamir, he just yearns to see St. Joseph.
“I’m just trying to get home to everything I own and everything I know,” he said.
Ken Newton can be reached
at kenn@npgco.com.
You could make a book or movie out of Mr. Pamir's story. I find myself thinking he was in the United States for so long and never caused a problem (as far as I know), let him come home, but. Then I find myself thinking if we let him come back we'll have to do it for everyone with a sad story. I don't know anything about David Brown of Brown Immigration Law (sounds impresive) I hope they can get Mr. Pamir home. I wish I could snap my fingers and get Gerry Spence (an attorney I've read about) on the case. Lets hope Edwards nightmare ends soon and he wakes up at home.
God Bless America, God Save The Republic
Posted by David on April 9, 2008 at 9:57 p.m. (Suggest removal)I hope we will be kept up to date on what is going on with this. Updates please.
God Bless America, God Save The Republic.
Posted by heritage on April 9, 2008 at 11:42 p.m. (Suggest removal)the federal government is using the post 9/11 laws to eject any legally resident alien who chooses legally to retain their citizenship of origin. it happened to us. we all need to ask ourselves, " are we safer because this government no longer considers each person as an individual? will keeping this little man out of the country prevent another attack?" the answer is a resounding NO, NO, NO.
Posted by donaldo on April 10, 2008 at 11:57 a.m. (Suggest removal)i have worked with ed pamire for those 18 years and can say he is a close freind. we have traveled together and are still freinds. he doesent deserve this , he has always been a very quiet layd back individual. he wouldnt hurt anyone. he has always been shy and reserved, i have tried time again to get him to open up and let go and have fun only to find him reserved in what others think about him.as an out going individual , loud and not carring what others thought of myself i found it difficult to get a long with edd at first but learned what kind of person he really is. he is a fine person who would let you push him untill he smiled. i hope edd will be comming home soon, i miss his smile, don griswold.
Posted by ksrogers2000 on April 11, 2008 at 8:56 a.m. (Suggest removal)if anyone would like to help bring our brother home please contact your local congressmans' office. Congressman Graves and his staff have been very helpful so far.
thank you
susan rogers
Posted by TimW on April 12, 2008 at 7:53 a.m. (Suggest removal)I have been Eds' Friend for more than 20 years, we have known each other since early high school. As for the amnesty program, I know that he registered because it was a subject that he and I discussed at great length. Being in the US illegally bothered him, he was very adamant about being legal and doing things right. I think this mess he is in is a crock....and he needs our help. he has been an upstanding citizen should be allowed to come home. I serve in the Navy to protect the very rights everyone has, but know I have to stand by and watch my friend have everything he has worked for stripped away because some government employee slacked on their job and didn't mail him a stinking card!
Posted by heritage on April 12, 2008 at 9:31 a.m. (Suggest removal)honestly, this whole debacle has less to do with a clerical error,( which obviously did happen) and more to do with the fact that the majority of the legislation which is supposed to be "keeping us safe" is just a crock. trying to get someone to listen to one man's plight is like pushing against the hoover dam. the expression, "don't make a federal case out of this" extends from the labyrinth of incomprehensible minutia which ensnares anyone caught in its web. once entangled, the "fly" can struggle, but the spider of the current anti- immigration mantra is there, waiting, poisoning everything . this poor man is one of thousands who are being treated as criminals. if this fellow had a glitch in his paperwork, if he can't produce documentation, are all the nay-sayers in this publication and across the land going to say that he should not be allowed to return to a country which he so obviously loves? does a lack of paperwork measure a man? is this country so intent upon isolationism that we can no longer consider the individual, or is mr pamir only another one of THEM? bring mr pamir home.
Posted by heritage on April 12, 2008 at 10:18 a.m. (Suggest removal)i just looked at the poll here in the paper, and am not surprised to see that less than 30% of people responding recognize injustice. this is the the heartLESS land.
Posted by ksrogers2000 on April 12, 2008 at 10:45 a.m. (Suggest removal)Please remember that this an election year. We should only vote into power people that help us "little people".
Posted by doxie on April 13, 2008 at 6:46 p.m. (Suggest removal)What I want to know is, if the immigration office said my brother was sent a ltter saying his status was denied, why didn't anyone from that office follow up? You would think they would want to see if he was still in the usa living, working and paying taxes. Write your congressman, and senator. This is very unfair
I was quite upset but not shocked to see the opinion poll on Ed's situation. I for one know that he did what was legally expected of him to become a legal citzen of this country, because I was married to him when he did it. I went to the immigration offices with him. I helped him obtain school records and other documents that the offices of immigration asked for. He had gotten the job at AG Processing and needed a social security card. He contacted the social security office which in turn led him to the offices of immigration. In the end, the government issued him his own social security card with his own number and he's been allowed to legally work in this country at the same job for the last 18 years. I think it is absolutely ridiculous that he isn't allowed to come home! He's as much an american citizen and has just as much right to be here as anyone who was born here!!! LET HIM COME HOME!
Posted by ksrogers2000 on April 14, 2008 at 2:18 a.m. (Suggest removal)Hey guys, thanks again for all your support. Please please please call congressman graves office in st joe and senator mckaskill. Tell them to bring my brother home
Posted by sj35 on April 14, 2008 at 10:41 p.m. (Suggest removal)Doxie? This is susan, nurhans sister. If this is brenda, please email me at ksrogers2000@msn.com
Thanks
How about a trade? This guy can come home (here) if officials round up 1000 illegals to send back now!
My point is that illegal immigration is so out of hand that stories like this that may have turned more sympathetic heads in the past are losing ground. I'd say let this guy come back quickly so those who support illegal immigration can't hold it over our heads when we try to turn the focus back to the real problem!
Posted by doxie on April 15, 2008 at 12:20 a.m. (Suggest removal)This is a completely different situation though. He's not an illegal. He filed all the necessary paperwork to become a citizen. Someone screwed up somewhere and lost his paperwork so he has no proof. I agree we have a problem with illegals, but that's not the case here.
Posted by moonfaerie63 on April 16, 2008 at 5:19 p.m. (Suggest removal)I was so shocked when I heard something about Ed! WOW!! I didn't know him well, but I do know that he was a very nice guy and I know that he doesn't deserve this! I hope that he can figure out a way to get back home soon! He knew me only as "Sunshine". Good luck!
Posted by ksrogers2000 on April 17, 2008 at 11:05 p.m. (Suggest removal)I just spent the past week in canada with my brother, ed. He is very thankful for all of the encouragement he is getting from you guys. Please keep the momentum going. He desperatly wants to come home
Posted by ksrogers2000 on April 22, 2008 at 4:12 p.m. (Suggest removal)brenda, can you give me a call? 804 501 8636
Posted by robyn74 on October 5, 2008 at 12:34 p.m. (Suggest removal)thanks susan
WOW THIS IS THE SAMETHING THAT HAPPEN TO ME AND MY HUSBAND HE IS NOW STUCK IN CANADA . HE WENT THERE BECUSE HIS MOTHER WAS ILL A MONTH AGO . HE WAS COMEING BACK HOME FRIDAY THE 3 AND I GET A PHONE CALL FROM HIM SAT NIGHT STATEING THEY WOULDNT ALLOW HIM ACROSS THE BORDER WE MISSED 1 APPOITMENT WITCH I SENT A LETTER 2 MONTHS BEFORE TTHE MEETING TO INS AND ALL OF A SUDDEN THEY NEVER GOT IT AND NOW HE IS STUCK IN CANADA CANT COME HOME WE HAVE TO DO ALL THE PAPERWORK OVER AGAIN THIS IS SUCH A MESS
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them.
Rules: We don't allow comments that degrade others on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation or disability. Epithets, abusive language and obscene comments will not be tolerated... nor will defamation. Brief quotes are okay as long as the source is given. Blatent cutting and pasting is not acceptable.Robust, even heated debate we like. Straying off-topic or flaming, we don't. Please read our user agreement.
Requires free stjoenews.net registration.